Welcome to the Islands-Vacations comparison of St. Lucia and Aruba as tropical vacation spots! If you’re considering a trip to the Caribbean but can’t decide between these two wonderful islands, you’ve come to the right place. Islands-Vacation team will help you to select one in St Lucia Vs Aruba.

An Overview of Saint Lucia
St. Lucia is a Caribbean island nation recognised for its breathtaking natural beauty and rich cultural legacy. St. Lucia is a wonderful vacation location for environment enthusiasts, with its verdant rainforests, renowned Pitons mountain range, and stunning beaches. But this island is home to more than just natural beauty; it also has a number of cultural attractions, such as the Diamond Falls Botanical Gardens and the St. Lucia Folk Research Centre.
Aruba Overview
Aruba, on the other hand, is a little island off Venezuela’s northwest coast. This sun-kissed paradise is well-known for its beautiful beaches and crystal-clear waters, making it a popular destination for beachgoers and water sports aficionados. Aside from its natural beauty, Aruba has a number of cultural attractions, including the Aruba Aloe Museum and Factory and the National Archaeological Museum Aruba. Aruba is the ideal destination for a relaxed and fun-filled holiday, thanks to its year-round sunny weather and vibrant nightlife.
So, which is the finest island for you? Both St. Lucia and Aruba have spectacular natural beauty as well as intriguing cultural activities. In the sections that follow, we’ll go into greater detail on each destination to help you make an informed decision.
Location : Aruba or St Lucia
When picking a vacation destination, location is a crucial thing to consider, and both St. Lucia and Aruba have a lot to offer in this regard.
St. Lucia is a Caribbean island republic located roughly midway between Martinique and St. Vincent. The island is approximately 27 miles long and 14 miles wide, and it is recognised for its hilly landscape, with the distinctive Pitons rising from the sea. Because St. Lucia is positioned north of the Caribbean’s Hurricane Belt, it experiences fewer severe storms than other Caribbean islands.
Aruba is a small island off Venezuela’s northwest coast, well outside the Caribbean’s Hurricane Belt. The island is only 19.6 miles long and 6.5 miles wide, with an arid climate and an average temperature of 82 degrees Fahrenheit. Aruba is about 15 miles north of Venezuela, making it the Caribbean island closest to South America.
St. Lucia is approximately 250 miles southeast of Puerto Rico and approximately 700 miles southeast of Miami in terms of closeness to other Caribbean islands and major cities. Aruba is approximately 1,500 miles east of Miami and approximately 35 miles northwest of Venezuela. Both islands are easily accessible by air, with direct flights from a variety of US and European locations.
Overall, both St. Lucia and Aruba provide a distinct setting with a wealth of natural beauty and closeness to other Caribbean islands and large cities.
Budget : St Lucia or Aruba
When it comes to vacation planning, it’s critical to examine your travel budget and how much you’re prepared to spend on flights, hotels, and daily costs. Let’s look at the average prices in both St. Lucia and Aruba.
Flights
The cost of flights to either destination might vary greatly depending on the time of year, the city from which you travel, and how far in advance you book. Flights to St. Lucia are slightly more expensive on average than flights to Aruba, with round-trip airfares starting about $600-$700 from major US cities. During the low season, flights to Aruba can be found for as little as $400-$500, with prices rising during peak travel times.
Accommodations
Both St. Lucia and Aruba have a variety of lodging alternatives to suit any budget, ranging from low-cost guesthouses to luxury resorts. A budget-friendly hotel in St. Lucia will cost you roughly $100-$200 per night, with rates increasing for more deluxe options. The typical cost of a hotel in Aruba is slightly higher, with costs beginning around $150-$200 per night for a budget-friendly alternative. However, it is crucial to realise that Aruba has a higher total cost of living, thus pricing for food and activities may be slightly higher on the island.
Daily Expenses
The daily cost of food, activities, and souvenirs might vary greatly depending on your own spending patterns, but you can expect to pay between $50 and $100 per day in either place. This is determined by where you eat, the activities you do, and the number of mementos you buy. Both islands provide plenty of free or low-cost options, making it easier to stay to a budget if that is a concern.
Seasonal Price Changes
When planning your trip, keep in mind that both St. Lucia and Aruba endure seasonal price fluctuations. The busy season in both destinations is from December to April, when prices for flights and accommodations are often higher. Prices drop dramatically during the low season, which lasts from May through November. It’s also worth mentioning that both islands offer a variety of special bargains and discounts throughout the year, so keep an eye out for these to save money.
Overall, both St. Lucia and Aruba have a variety of hotel options to suit any budget, with average daily prices ranging from $50 to $100. It is worthwhile to consider the time of year you travel and hunt for special bargains to save money.
Which Island Have Best Beaches : Aruba or St Lucia
When selecting a tropical holiday destination, one important element to consider is the quality of the beaches. Both St. Lucia and Aruba boast a plethora of stunning beaches, each with its own distinct personality. Which island, though, has the nicest beaches?
St. Lucia has a multitude of stunning beaches, each with its own distinct personality. Reduit Beach, located in the island’s northwest, is a popular choice due to its white sandy beaches and crystal-clear waters. Marigot Bay, famed for its beautiful setting and calm waves, and Anse Chastanet, which offers stunning views of the Pitons mountain range, are two more prominent beaches on the island.
Aruba is well-known for its beautiful beaches with fluffy white sands and turquoise waters. Eagle Beach, on the island’s western shore, is a popular choice due to its beautiful white sands and quiet waves. Palm Beach, on the island’s northwest coast, is another favourite choice, with its long stretch of sandy beach and crystal-clear waters.
Overall, it’s tough to tell which island has the “greatest” beaches, as both St. Lucia and Aruba have a plethora of stunning possibilities. Finally, it comes down to personal preference and what you’re looking for in a beach holiday. Both islands have a variety of lovely beaches with white sandy coasts and crystal-clear oceans, so you can’t go wrong with either.
Nightlife : St Lucia Vs Aruba
If you want to experience a busy nightlife while on vacation, both St. Lucia and Aruba have plenty to offer. Let’s take a closer look at each destination’s nighttime scene.
St. Lucia is recognised for its vibrant nightlife, featuring a variety of pubs, clubs, and entertainment alternatives. Throughout the year, the island is home to a variety of stylish pubs and clubs, as well as live music events and festivals. Rodney Bay, which has a variety of late-night bars and clubs, is a popular nightlife destination. If gambling is your thing, the island boasts a few options.
Aruba is recognised for its vibrant nightlife, with a diverse selection of pubs, clubs, and entertainment alternatives. There are several casinos on the island, which are known for their live music and late-night ambience. Aruba boasts a variety of pubs and clubs to fit any taste, from beach bars to nightclubs, in addition to its casinos.
Notable Events and Festivals: Throughout the year, both St. Lucia and Aruba host a variety of events and festivals, many of which centre on music and nightlife. The Saint Lucia Jazz Festival, which attracts top musical acts from around the world, and the Saint Lucia Food and Rum Festival, which highlights the island’s culinary and rum-making traditions, are both held in St. Lucia. Throughout the year, Aruba hosts a number of music events, including the Soul Beach Music Festival and the Aruba International Film Festival.
Both St. Lucia and Aruba have a busy nighttime culture, with a variety of bars, clubs, and entertainment alternatives. Both islands have plenty to offer, whether you want to dance the night away at a nightclub or enjoy live music and a cocktail at a beach bar.
Things to Do : St Lucia or Aruba
When it comes to activities, both St. Lucia and Aruba provide plenty to keep you busy during your holiday. Let’s look more closely at what each island has to offer.
Outdoor and Adventure Activities
For the adventurous traveller, both St. Lucia and Aruba offer a variety of outdoor and adventure activities. Hike and zip line through the rainforest in St. Lucia, go snorkelling or scuba diving in the crystal-clear waters, or take a boat excursion to explore the island’s stunning coastline. Aruba also has a variety of water sports available, including snorkelling, scuba diving, and windsurfing, as well as outdoor activities like horseback riding and off-road ATV rides.
Cultural and Historical Sites
Both St. Lucia and Aruba have a rich cultural and historical legacy, and both islands offer several attractions to explore. In St. Lucia, you can learn about the island’s history and culture by visiting the Diamond Falls Botanical Gardens and the St. Lucia Folk Research Centre. Aruba also boasts a number of cultural sites to visit, including the Aruba Aloe Museum and Factory and the Aruba National Archaeological Museum.
Water-Based Activities
Of course, no trip to the Caribbean would be complete without some beach time. St. Lucia and Aruba both have stunning beaches with crystal-clear waves and white sand. You may relax on the beach or enjoy water activities like stand-up paddleboarding or kayaking in St. Lucia. Aruba is particularly well-known for its stunning beaches and water sports, including jet skiing, parasailing, and kiteboarding.
Overall, St. Lucia and Aruba both have a variety of outdoor and adventure activities, cultural and historical sites, and beach and water-based activities to keep you amused during your stay.
How to Get There : Aruba or St Lucia
Getting to St. Lucia or Aruba is simple, as both islands have significant airports with direct flights from a variety of places. Let’s dig deeper into the details.
Airports
Hewanorra International Airport (UVF) serves St. Lucia and is located in the island’s south. American Airlines, Delta, and United are among the major airlines that serve the airport. Queen Beatrix International Airport (AUA) serves Aruba and is located in the capital city of Oranjestad. American Airlines, Delta, and Southwest are among the major airlines that serve the airport.
Transportation
St. Lucia and Aruba both provide a variety of transportation options for getting about the islands. To get around St. Lucia, you can rent a car, use a cab, or use the island’s public transportation system. You can rent a car, use a taxi, or use the island’s public bus system, known as the Arubus. Both islands also include a variety of tour operators who provide guided excursions as well as transportation to major locations.
Visas and Travel Documents
A passport is required for admission into St. Lucia, with a valid passport required for stays of up to six months. Citizens of certain nations, notably the United States, Canada, and the majority of European countries, can enter Aruba with only a government-issued ID. Before travelling to any country, always check the visa and travel document requirements.
Overall, both St. Lucia and Aruba are easily accessible by flight, with a variety of transportation choices available once you arrive. For travel to St. Lucia, you must have a valid passport and verify the visa and travel document requirements for your specific destination.
Finally, Aruba Or St. Lucia
After evaluating the numerous variables of location, travel budget, nightlife, activities, and how to get there, it’s time to choose between St. Lucia and Aruba.
To recap, both St. Lucia and Aruba have spectacular natural beauty, including green rainforests and gorgeous beaches. Both islands also feature a variety of housing options to suit any budget, with average daily prices ranging between $50 and $100. Both islands offer a thriving nightlife scene, with a variety of pubs, clubs, and entertainment options. Both islands include a wide variety of outdoor and adventure activities, cultural and historical sites, and beach and water-based activities. Finally, both islands are easily accessible by plane, and once there, a variety of transportation alternatives are available.
So, which is the finest island for you? Both St. Lucia and Aruba are fantastic vacation spots, and the choice is ultimately a matter of personal preference. St. Lucia may be the correct choice for you if you’re seeking for a tropical paradise with magnificent natural beauty and a rich cultural past. Aruba, on the other hand, may be the perfect choice if you’re looking for a sun-soaked paradise with magnificent beaches and a vibrant nightlife scene.
Overall, St. Lucia and Aruba both have a richness of beauty, culture, and entertainment, making either island an excellent choice for a pleasant and relaxing holiday.